Second Life Avatar Sued for Copyright Infringement
Right in time for the July 4th holiday week (after all, what’s more American than demanding your day in court?), businessman Kevin Alderman and his lawyer have just filed suit against someone who goes by the name Volkov Catteneo, for copyright infringement.
This would be just one IP dispute in thousands handled by US courts every day, except for two unique features: the contention is over a virtual sex bed which doesn’t exist, and the named defendant also doesn’t exist. As such, the suit will establish an enormous precedent in the new realm of virtual world law, however it shakes out.
I should back up and explain those last three sentences.
Linden Lab, the company which provides Second Life’s virtual land (i.e. server grid) and means to explore it (i.e. interface software and currency) has since late 2003 allowed its users to retain the underlying intellectual property rights to all objects and programs created in the world with its internal building and scripting tools.
This policy unleashed enormous user-created innovation, and enabled thousands of users to make a living with their virtual content creation. Alderman, known in Second Life as Stroker Serpentine (pictured) is one of SL’s leading entrepreneurs; his SL-based adult entertainment industry has become so successful, he recently sold his X-rated Amsterdam island in Second Life to a real world Dutch media firm for $50,000 very real dollars.
For the last fours years, this IP rights policy has been working more less as designed, but those who follow the virtual world business have been waiting for the other shoe to drop: what happens when one avatar tries to sue another avatar for copyright infringement in an actual court?
It finally has: Alderman/Serpentine believes Catteno is selling unauthorized copies of his SexGen bed, a piece of furniture with special embedded animations that enable players to more or less recreate an adult film with their avatars. Alderman sells his version for the L$ equivalent of USD$45, and they’ve helped make his fortune. Catteno is selling his alleged knockoff for a third that price, undercutting him.
But who does Kevin Alderman sue? Since SL users have no obligation to reveal their real life identity to other players, all the relevant data exists only on Linden’s servers and files. This is why Alderman is threatening to subpoena Linden Lab for this data, so he can bring the real person behind Catteno to trial.
I contacted Stroker Serpentine in Second Life and asked why he chose going to trial. Volkov Catteneo’s account was created in February 2007, while Stroker is a longtime and well-loved player. Why not just voice his complaint about Catteno to the SL community, so they can ostracize him and his allegedly infringing beds?
Stroker tells me he did try that method in another case, but ironically, it backfired. “[T]he last time this happened I confronted the individual about it and requested that they cease and desist…,” he says, “I was made out to be a bully and dragged through the [SL community] forums.” Linden Lab has a system for letting users file DMCA suits against each other; Stroker tried that twice, but wasn’t happy with how Linden responded. So he found a law firm specializing in copyright/trademark disputes. “We weighed all alternatives and listened to a lot of advice. So here we are.”
Trouble is, Catteno tells Reuters he doesn’t have any real world data on file with Linden Lab. (A plausible claim; since ‘06, it’s no longer necessary to register a credit card or other identifying data with Linden Lab.) I imagine the company could supply Alderman and his lawyer’s with Catteno’s IP address, and let them deal with it from there. Or if it goes forward in court, perhaps the judge will review the case, decide it’s fundamentally nuts, and toss it. Then again, the court might let it go to trial, as it did with another user lawsuit against Linden Lab, and what happens then is anyone’s guess. Numerous companies which depend on user-created content are waiting to see. In any case, may the best avatar win.
Update, 9:00am: For the legally minded, Reuters’ SL reporters (who broke this story) have put the actual legal form in .pdf at this link.
Entropia Universe: A Better Second Life?
notice the exchange of value into and out of the game
– Augustine
Depending on who you listen to, virtual worlds are the new black. Second Life needs no introduction and yesterday rumors surfaced that Sony was in talks to acquire Club Penguin for $500+ million.
To date there are two leading online spaces. World of Warcraft has been an unrivaled success, bringing Dungeon and Dragons style fantasy role playing to an audience in excess of 8 million. At the opposing end is Second Life with its embrace of capitalism and intellectual property rights.
What happened if you combined both?
Enter Entropia Universe
Set in a Sci-Fi future players assume the roles of colonists who must develop the untamed planet of Calypso. Game play is open across a number of different fields. Players who prefer a World of Warcraft style experience can undertake quests and join in groups to hunt and fight monsters. Mining is an option for those who don’t like swinging a sword. Moving towards a more Second Life experience, players are able to own and run shops, manufacture goods, own land and build on that land, as well as being able to trade, buy, sell and create goods and services.
The addition that makes Entropia Universe a direct competitor to Second Life though is money. Like Second Life, the in-world currency in Entropia Universe can be converted to US dollars. Unlike the Linden dollar that continues to decline in value, the Entropia Universe PED can be traded at a fixed exchange rate of 10 PED to $1 USD.
Players are able to buy PED’s to use in-world or can transfer PED’s made in-world, out.
But there’s more to Entropia Universe than just the ability to transfer cash in and out. A MasterCard branded ATM Cash Card is available to players which allow direct withdrawal of funds earned in-world. Banking is also taken seriously, unlike the unregulated wild west of Second Life with it’s various in-world ponzi schemes. Entropia Universe recently sold 5 banking licenses for the amazing sum of $404,000 USD.
It all sounds great on paper, but how does it actually play?
Signing up is free, though personal details are not optional. Whilst you could probably enter false information, Entropia Universe does want to know who you are.
If Entropia Universe was to be judged alone on its installation procedures, there would be a lot less than the over 500,000 registered users. It’s awful. The Windows only client is over 1GB in size and can only be downloaded from the one server using FTP. If you eventually mange to connect to the server, and it took me a several hours, you then have to wait an awfully long time for the download. Best I could get initially on a 2mb Cable connection was 20kbs download speed with an estimated time to download of 17 hours! In part it could have been a timing issue. I tried to download during the middle of the day European time (where the company is located). TechCrunch writer Nick Gonzalez reported a 4 hour download from the US during the European night.
A full sleep later I finally had it.
Login is simple although settings should be watched. I had regular issues staying connected until I dropped by internet speed settings to a much lower figure than my actual internet speed.
Users/ players must setup an avatar with a bewildering array of options. Entropia Universe claims that they have the best avatars in the business and it’s a fair claim. Much nicer looking than Second Life with more customization options than you’ll probably ever want to use.
In-world is good. I wouldn’t call it excellent but it’s definitely a slicker look and feel than Second Life. Moving around is easy enough, and once short-cuts and mouse options are learnt it’s a pleasurable interface to use.
I took a tour of Calypso Island and teleported to a number of other locations as well. The non-user created areas look professional, but in some ways, compared to Second Life, it felt a little boring. Second Life would have to be 99% ugly but it’s the raw passion of the user generated buildings that give it appeal.
The graphics engine behind Entropia Universe purrs. Even with relatively low settings the experience was seamless, and despite entering areas with large gatherings of people there were zero lag issues, a constant negative in Second Life.
I’d need to spend more time in-world to get a better feeling for all the possibilities Entropia Universe provides. You can’t fly around and teleport at will in Entropia Universe like you can in Second Life so things do take a bit longer, and yet flying is not a feature you come to expect in virtual worlds if you’re not an existing Second Life user.
Is Entropia Universe a better Second Life?
It depends on what you like. With a retention rate of 16% for Second Life amongst US users, it’s clear that many don’t enjoy what Second Life has to offer, despite the hype. One criticism I hear regularly about Second Life is that it’s aimless; it’s not a game so there is nothing really to do other than enjoy virtual sex and play Tringo. Now before I am shouted down by a legion of Second Life groupies, I do see Second Life’s appeal as a creative and social space, but not everyone wants to get online and build virtual strip clubs or interrupt interviews with flying penises.
Entropia Universe offers the best of both Second Life and World of Warcraft style virtual worlds. The creativity and capitalism of Second Life can be experienced along with solid game play and decent graphics. If they can fix the issues with downloading the client (hint: bittorrent) and you don’t mind downloading a 1gb file it’s definitely worth a look. If it builds members so the social aspect becomes stronger, we could well be looking at a better Second Life, and already one that will appeal to a much more broader audience.
-
Archives
- September 2011 (4)
- August 2011 (4)
- July 2011 (2)
- June 2011 (4)
- May 2011 (12)
- April 2011 (7)
- March 2011 (18)
- February 2011 (17)
- January 2011 (6)
- December 2010 (7)
- November 2010 (4)
- October 2010 (13)
-
Categories
- $100
- $189 PC
- 1 person acapella
- 12.47 megapixel sensor
- 16gb
- 1800free411
- 1TB hard drive
- 2008
- 22281738
- 23769345
- 23771330
- 2TB
- 320GB 2.5-inch hard drive
- 3D
- 3D fabrication
- 3G
- 45nm
- 57-inch
- 64-core
- 746
- a million channels
- AACS
- AAPL
- acquisitions
- ad spending declines
- adobe photoshop express
- advertising
- advertising network
- adwords
- air horn
- alexa
- alexa rank
- all-in-one
- alternative energy clean technology
- amazon
- amazon fps
- AMOLED
- analytics software
- anime song generator
- answer
- aol
- APB
- appleTV
- aquantive
- architecture
- archos PMPs
- art advertisement
- articles
- asus
- Atom 330
- atom n270 performance
- audi
- audio watermarking
- baby monitor
- balloon in space
- basketball
- battery
- benq projectors
- best buy
- beyond web 2.0
- blackberry
- blackjack
- blog hack
- bluetooth
- box office earnings
- brand protection counterfeiting
- broadband
- broadband subscribers
- browser-based video
- building
- building faces
- burn
- buzzdash
- byo
- cameraphone
- cancer
- canon
- canon EOS 40D
- captcha
- case precedent
- casio exilim
- casual games
- cell phone
- cell phone mobile payments
- cellphone
- cellular over WiFi
- censorship
- channels
- characteristics of web 3.0
- charger
- cheer
- chipin
- cinematic effects
- circuit city
- citizen journalism
- clean technology
- clean water
- cleantech
- clickz
- clipblast
- CMOS
- coal plant
- code based promotions
- coke
- cold boot
- collapsible
- color scheme
- colored katydids
- combustion
- commonangels
- compactflash
- comparison engines
- compete
- conference
- consumer behavior
- consumer market
- consumer market research
- consumer power
- consumer purchasing
- context-based clustering
- contextual commerce
- copyright
- copyright infringement case precedent
- copyright law
- core 2 duo
- core i7
- corian Z
- coscripter
- counterfeiting
- crack detector
- crazyegg
- Creative Commons
- CTR
- current from vibrations
- customer
- customer loyalty
- customer service
- DAP
- DDR2
- DDR3
- deeplinking
- dell
- Dell XPS m1330
- democracy player
- design
- desktop
- didja
- diesel
- digg
- DIGIC II
- digital cameras
- digital cinema
- digital image sensor
- digital marketing
- digital media
- discover music
- distribution service
- DIY
- DNA art
- donation
- DPAC
- dpreview.com
- Dr. Augustine Fou
- DRM
- DTCP-IP
- dubai. energy efficient
- dvr
- e-paper
- earphones
- earth 2tech
- ebook
- ebooks
- eee box
- eggfusion
- electric car
- embed google maps
- embedded
- enthusiast
- entropia
- entropia 3D rendering
- epson 3LCD
- EU
- evolution from web 2.0
- exilim 12 megapixel
- expandable
- experiential marketing
- facebook ebay
- fake ID
- fax
- ferrari
- fiber optic tablecloth
- fiber to the premises
- fingerprint
- fios
- firefighting
- flash
- flavored water
- flexible OLED display
- Flextronics
- flickr
- flickr photo news
- flickrcash
- flickrcash flickr photos
- flickrcash flickr search stock photography
- flickrcash flickr search stock photography Dr. Augustine Fou
- flickrcash stock photography
- FlickrSlidr
- fluorescent lighting
- foleo
- food poisoning
- footagesandbox
- fotolog
- foveon
- framed pages
- frequent flyer miles
- freshbooks
- fruit harvesting machine
- fruit tattoo
- fujitsu
- gaming user generated
- genwi
- geothermal energy
- getty
- getty audio
- Getty Images
- getty stock images footage
- gift of music
- Glenn Gabe
- global warming
- glucose to fuel
- gmail
- gmail auto responder hack
- gmail hack
- gmail tasks
- go-digital marketing blog
- google adwords
- google analytics
- google checkout
- google chrome cache
- google earth
- Google Flight Simluator
- google image search
- google maps
- google online security
- google phone
- google powerpoint
- google talk
- google zeitgeist
- GPU
- green
- green car
- greeting cards
- groceries
- group buying
- group calling
- group chat
- group chief digital officer
- GSM
- gtalk
- GYI
- H and M clothing in SIMS
- h.264 hd encoding chip
- hacking gmail yahoo mail
- handwritten blogs
- hard drive new magnetic tech
- harry potter
- hcg
- HD projector
- hd-dvd
- hdr
- hdtv
- headphones
- hearst
- hitachi
- home entertainment system
- home phone
- hot or not
- hot or not business model
- hotornot
- how fast is intel atom n270
- hsdpa
- html converter
- hulu
- human-powered search
- hybrid mini cooper
- hydrogen generation
- hyphen digital
- i7
- iChat screensharing
- identity theft
- IE7
- ikea hotels
- ilike
- image manipulation
- images
- imagetrail
- implants
- incoming links
- incubator
- induction cooking
- industrial design
- industries
- instant messaging
- INTC
- integrated marketing
- intel
- intel 45nm
- intel atom 330 vs core 2 duo
- intel bearlake
- intel core 2 duo
- invalidation
- inventions
- inventory-centralized retail
- investment
- investors
- IP law
- iPhone
- iphone ringtones
- ipod
- ipod to TV
- ipod touch
- itunes
- jabra
- jerry yang
- jetblue
- jing
- jkwedding
- jkwedding video
- jkweddingdance
- joost
- jpeg
- Katerina
- keyboard
- kitchen
- kodak
- kodak digital camera
- laptop hard drive
- Larry Lessig
- lawsuit
- lawyers
- LCD
- LCD touch screen
- lcd tv
- LED
- LED backlight LCD
- LED display
- led lighting
- lego scale model
- levis
- levitation
- LG KS20
- li-ion batteries
- light
- light-sensitive
- lightbox
- linux
- liquid cooling for the masses
- low light
- LuckyOliver
- lympus
- macbook benchmark
- macbook pro
- made in china
- magnetic fields
- mahalo
- mailbox
- malware
- marketing
- marketplace answers
- me.dium
- media encoder
- medical images
- medical record
- megan fox
- meizu
- metrics
- microprojector
- microSD
- microsoft
- microsoft office
- microsoft yahoo google advertising
- mini
- mini projector
- miniPC
- miro
- missing link marketing
- MIT
- MMO
- motorola
- mp3
- mrm worldwide
- multi touch
- multi-point video posting
- multi-touch LCD
- multiple copies of same program
- music
- myspace news
- NAND
- nanoglue
- nanoprojector
- nanosolar
- nas
- nasa
- nbc venture capital
- NEC LCD
- nehalem
- network print sharing
- neuros OSD
- nokia
- not hackable
- not selling well
- NowPublic
- ntp
- nvidia
- Objects D'esire
- obvious
- octo-core
- October 28
- OLED
- Olympus
- omnicom
- online game
- online identity theft
- online money management
- online music
- online world game
- openCola
- overclocking
- paid reviews
- palm
- panasonic 12 megapixel hd shooter
- parakey
- password
- password managers
- patent
- patent lawsuit
- patent reform
- paypal
- pc
- PDF by email
- peonies
- personal asset
- peter kim
- pharming
- Philips
- philips ambilight
- phishing
- photo editing
- photo greetings
- photo tagging
- photobucket valuation
- photos
- photos flickr creativecommons
- photos for blogs
- photoshop
- Phreetings
- piclens
- pico projector
- PictureSandbox
- piezoelectric
- pingdom
- platial google mymaps
- player
- polls
- pollution detector
- polyesters
- polymer
- porsche design
- portable media
- post widgets to multiple sites
- postage
- pr
- prevent image download
- print server
- privacy
- prostockmaster
- prosumer
- prototype
- question
- RAM
- rank
- raw food
- RAZR 2
- rebate
- recorder
- remix
- remote control cell phone
- research
- restart windows
- retail
- retail theft
- revenue share
- RFID
- RFID cards
- RIAA
- ringle
- robert scoble
- roi of social marketing
- rss
- rubik's cube
- sageTV
- salesforce
- Samsung
- samsung cell phones
- samsung ssd
- sanyo xacti
- satl water
- screencapture
- screencasting
- Scribd
- Scribd investment VC
- scripps
- scrub clipboard
- sdhc
- search
- search innovations
- secondlife
- secondlife virtual advertising
- security loophole
- semacodes on ads
- set-top box
- seth godin
- sharp LCD
- shopping cart install
- sigma
- sign
- single login
- site stats
- skype
- slapvid
- SMS
- social marketing
- social media marketing
- social network
- social networking aggregator
- social surfing
- solar
- solar panel installation
- solar power thermal
- Solectron
- songbird
- sony OLED
- sony TFT
- spam
- speakers
- speed of information
- spffy
- spider web
- spiralfrog
- SSD
- starbucks publicity
- stars
- stats
- stephen hawking
- stereolithography 3D printing
- stereoscopic display
- Steve Fossett
- stock images
- stock photos
- streetview
- stylish projectors
- sugar
- supercomputer
- surface
- surveillance
- sweepstakes fraud
- swfir
- sync photos
- tablet PC
- tapefailure
- taxes
- taxonomy
- techcrunch
- TED2007
- tesla
- the long tail
- the perfect babe
- theives
- thermoacoustic
- thin film battery
- thin TV
- three gorges dam
- tivo
- toaster
- toolkit
- tools of production
- tornado
- toshiba hard drive
- trademark yoga
- transistor
- trash balls
- treo
- trustcode
- trusted opinion
- twango
- Uncategorized
- unlocked iPhone
- usb 2.0
- USB hub
- usb monitors
- USPTO
- VC
- vCore
- vdimm
- venture capital
- veotag
- verizon
- veryfunnyads
- VGA server
- video
- video editing
- video fingerprint tech
- video search
- videoegg
- videos
- virgin charter service
- virtual PC
- virtual sales associates
- virtual world
- visa
- voip
- voip over WiFi
- vonage
- watch
- watches
- wave energy
- weather
- web 2.0
- web 2.0 participation
- web 3.0
- web analytics
- web API
- web conferencing
- web design
- web OS
- webcam
- webmail
- wells fargo
- whatinhellwastheiragencythinking
- whatinhellweretheythinking
- whois
- widget metric traffic visitors views
- WiFi
- wifi extender
- WiFi repeater
- wiFi SD cards
- wiki
- windows
- windows vista
- wine high end
- wireless
- wireless USB
- witricity
- WOM
- woot
- word of mouth
- worldview
- WSJ
- xcavator
- xerox search
- xgrid
- yahoo
- YCombinator
- youlicense
- youtube
- youtube shooter
- zap
- zonbu
- zooomr
- zune
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS